The amount of energy consumed by a typical extrusion operation makes it an obvious target for reduction.
Petfood companies from giants like Mars Petcare US and Nestlé Purina PetCare to specialists like Canidae Pet Food and Natura Pet Products have been opening or retrofitting exciting eco-friendly facilities to great fanfare over the past few years. But executives from these and other manufacturers would say that making petfood more sustainable usually starts with the basics, including energy-intensive processing.
“Prior to sustainability becoming the hot buzzword, it was called cost efficiency,” said Terry Block, president of Nestlé Purina’s North American division. “As you reduce energy and water, you reduce costs, and we have been on that curve for over a decade.”
The amount of energy consumed by a typical extrusion operation makes it an obvious target for reduction. According to Tjitze Smit, petfood division manager for Graintec A/S, the extrusion process can use up to 380 kilowatt hours (kWh) of energy per ton of final product (Figure 1). The drying part of the process accounts for the largest use of energy (Figure 2).
Recovery of dryer exhaust and other processing air can save 20 to 100 kWh of thermal energy per ton of final product, Smit said in his Petfood Forum Europe 2011 presentation, “Energy recovery and odor reduction in petfood production.” Often the most cost-effective solutions integrate technologies to reduce not only energy use but also odor and carbon dioxide emissions.
Smit suggested four potential solutions for recovering energy from the drying process:
Thermal and mechanical energy are the major inputs for extrusion, with the typical operation using a 1:2 ratio of mechanical to thermal energy, according to Galen Rokey, process technology manager for Wenger Manufacturing. During a Wenger seminar for petfood producers in the UK in June 2011, he said this ratio affects utility and equipment wear costs and influences sustainability.
The costs are significant, Rokey added, with mechanical costing about 2.5 times more than thermal for the same unit of energy. Wenger has found these averages applicable in almost every region of the world:
Rokey shared an exercise in which the 1:2 ratio was altered by reducing thermal energy by 25% and 43%, with the latter resulting in a 1:1 mechanical:thermal ratio. This changed the energy inputs to the extrusion process, dramatically driving up utility costs and, to a lesser extent, equipment wear costs (Figure 3).
Figure 1. Energy consumption during extrusion: The feed extrusion process consumes a significant amount of electrical and thermal energy, said Tjitze Smit of Graintec A/S in his Petfood Forum Europe 2011 presentation, “Energy recovery and odor reduction in petfood production.”
The bottom line: To maximize efficiency, try to increase thermal energy inputs—look at steam in the preconditioner barrel—and decrease mechanical energy, especially within the extruder.
Steam heat efficiency is key, too. David Degelau, engineer and certified steam system specialist for Hydro-Thermal Corp., detailed the energy losses in a typical industrial heating system in his Petfood Forum 2011 presentation, “Process heating: temperature stability under dynamic flow rates” (Figure 4):
According to Degelau, direct steam injection (DSI) can mitigate these losses. “DSI uses 100% of the steam’s heat energy by adding steam directly to the processing fluid.” This direct contact heating, he added, delivers benefits such as:
To help determine what type of heating system is best for your operation, Degelau suggested doing an energy comparison. Several energy calculators are available online, including ones from the US Department of Energy, Hydro-Thermal and Sempra Energy.
Waste reduction and recovery can also make processing more sustainable, experts from Extru-Tech Inc. said in the February 2009 issue of The Extru-Technician. The first step is to review operational procedures and look for clear waste targets—for example, nonessential extruder water injection.
To recover as much of the remaining waste as possible, start by calculating the amount of rework you can reintroduce into the raw ingredient stream without creating more waste or off-spec product. Base this calculation on extrusion capacity rates and the product formulation, Extru-Tech said, considering all aspects such as starch gelatinization, appearance, durability, density and nutrition.
Dry waste (fines generated during extrusion, with moisture less than 13%) is best recycled by grinding and adding back to the raw material batch mixer at rates of 0-5%, according to Extru-Tech. The company offers a proprietary waste recovery system (WRS) for wet waste, which is typically created during system startup, shutdown or process interruptions and collected from the preconditioner downspout and extruder die. A WRS can continuously convey, liquefy and inject the recovered material as slurry directly into the preconditioner without any operational changes to the extruder, Extru-Tech said.
In a case study of a plant with a WRS facilitating wet waste from an extrusion line producing premium dog food, Extru-Tech said its findings showed a collective annual savings of US$123,455: US$2,906 of energy savings, US$3,844 of water savings and recovered materials worth US$116,455.
Videos: How to save energy
Watch Tjitze Smit, petfood division manager for Graintec A/S, during Petfood Forum Europe 2011, discussing calculation of energy consumption and the benefits of heat pumps.
Presentation: Learn more about process heating
David Degelau, engineer and certified steam system specialist for Hydro-Thermal Corp., explains ways to save energy with industrial heating systems in his Petfood Forum 2011 presentation: "Process Heating – Temperature Stability Under Dynamic Flow Rates."
See the full results of the survey sent to the Petfood Industry audience on sustainability.
Companies like The Honest Kitchen, Pulse Canada and Mars Petcare are making "green" ingredients a top priority
An industry survey shows petfood companies are responding to consumer demand but have some concerns
Processors should carefully develop, validate and implement an effective kill step to support production of pathogen-free petfoods
Advances in extrusion, drying and cooling technology and products
Extrusion extravaganza 2010
Get even more online in our database of the latest equipment in all things extrusion, drying and cooling. Check out www.petfoodindustry.com/products.aspx and click "Equipment" or visit www.petfoodindustry.com/ExtrusionExtras.aspx for additional information on th
Canidae's Single Grain Protein Plus dog food line is designed to complement the company's existing lines, including its grain-free offerings and meat-based diets.
Explore the science behind extrusion technologies in the article, "Applying polymer science to extrusion and drying of petfoods"
Figure 2. Energy suckers: Drying accounts for the largest use of thermal energy during extrusion, at 60%, plus another 13% of electrical energy, according to Tjitze Smit of Graintec A/S.
Figure 3. Processing efficiency effect on energy and wear costs: The typical petfood extrusion process uses a 1:2 ratio of mechanical to thermal energy, according to Galen Rokey of Wenger Manufacturing. Increasing mechanical while reducing thermal energy can dramatically increase costs.
Figure 4. Energy losses in the heating process: A typical industrial heating system can lose a significant amount of energy, according to David Degelau of Hydro-Thermal Corp. He presented at Petfood Forum 2011 on “Process heating: temperature stability under dynamic flow rates.”
--- Thank you for your patience ----
If you have any issues logging in or any other need feel free to contact us.