Create a free PetfoodIndustry account to continue reading

Human-grade meat versus sustainability creates a pet food dichotomy

The pet food industry may need to use fewer resources in consideration of what others need in perpetuity.

Professional headshot of a bald man with facial hair wearing a dark gray blazer and black shirt Headshot
French bulldog looking curiously at blue earth-like spheres in metal food bowl
Tim Wall | DALL-E

Two trends contradict each other in the pet food industry. Pet owners demand reducing the environmental degradation associated with pet food production. At the same time, they demand formulations made with high quantities of human-grade muscle meat. A study published in the Journal of Cleaner Production, addressed this dichotomy.

In contrast to earlier studies on pet foods’ contribution to climate change, this study differentiated between products made with animal tissues that would otherwise have gone to waste and those ingredients that compete with the human food stream. When pet food makers use organ meats, rendered by-products and other tissues that humans no longer desire in their own diets, it reduces the discarded nutrition. In my opinion, this better honors the lives of those livestock. I’m no vegetarian, but unlike my German grandfather, who relished Braunschweiger and other organ meats ground up and stuffed into intestines, I rarely eat offal. That doesn’t mean kidneys and livers aren’t nutritious, and there’s no reason dogs and cats shouldn’t eat them. It’s just that humans tend to mimic the eating habits of wealthier humans, and beef steak has traditionally been the meat of the upper classes in Europe and the U.S., notwithstanding a bit of goose pate.

It’s important for owners to know that choosing grain-free, wet or raw foods can result in higher impacts compared to standard dry kibble foods. 
 - John Harvey, University of Edinburgh