Create a free PetfoodIndustry account to continue reading

How to convene a GRAS panel for novel pet food ingredients

While not required by FDA, a panel may be the best means of confirming GRAS status for pet food manufacturers.

Convening a panel of experts to determine the GRAS status of a pet food ingredient has advantages, whether or not you intend to notify FDA of the outcome. | endostock, Fotolia.com
Convening a panel of experts to determine the GRAS status of a pet food ingredient has advantages, whether or not you intend to notify FDA of the outcome. | endostock, Fotolia.com

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has recently provided draft guidance on best practices for convening a GRAS (Generally Recognized As Safe) expert panel (see sidebar, “Relevant FDA links”). The determination of a substance as GRAS is one means to allow for use of a novel ingredient in pet foods distributed in the United States. This method of documenting safety has its advantages and disadvantages over other processes (e.g., filing a Food Additive Petition or an AAFCO Feed Ingredient Definition), but is best reserved for substances where the vast bulk of the available supportive data is in the public domain. Formal notification of FDA as to a determination of a substance as GRAS is not legally required, but for practical purposes is usually prudent in the case of animal feed ingredients. 

Whether notification to FDA is made or not, convening a panel of experts to review and opine on the available data to support safe use of an ingredient is perhaps the best means of confirming GRAS status. To that end, pet food and ingredient companies considering this approach should take heed of FDA's advice in forming and convening a panel. The 30-page document offers significant detail in this regard. Considerations should include:

The experts comprising a GRAS panel are essentially serving as proxies for the scientific community at large. No one person can be an expert on everything, so diversity in training and perspective among panelists is critical in ensuring that all aspects of safety are addressed. While the number of panelists needed to attain this wide range of expertise may vary, I have found in my experience serving on quite a few panels that at least three experts are usually needed.