Create a free PetfoodIndustry account to continue reading

Clashing trends create pet food sustainability dichotomies

For the pet food industry, competing trends create contradictions that challenge the development of sustainable business models from ingredient sourcing and manufacturing to marketing, packaging and distribution.

Professional headshot of a bald man with facial hair wearing a dark gray blazer and black shirt Headshot
(Willee Cole | BigStock.com)
(Willee Cole | BigStock.com)

Sustainability has become both a buzzword and a necessity, both green-washed jargon and inevitable societal change. For the pet food industry, competing trends create contradictions that challenge the development of sustainable business models from ingredient sourcing and manufacturing to marketing, packaging and distribution. Nevertheless, dog, cat and other pet food professionals have found ways to translate the love for animals inherent in the industry to caring for the wider living world and its inhabitants.

In 1987, the United Nations Brundtland Commission defined sustainability as “meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” Sustainability has expanded to include a wide range of environmental, social and economic issues, many of which relate to the pet food industry. Environmental sustainability includes the effects of growing crops and livestock used as pet food ingredients. Agricultural systems affect the ecosystems around them, along with local economies. Maintaining functional environments ensures the long-term economic sustainability of the farms themselves. Farmers depend on rain and aquifers, soil microbes, pollinator insects and many other aspects of the natural world that can be disrupted by human activities. Those ecosystem services ensure the farms can continue employing people from surrounding communities while supporting the overall global economy. Those people growing, harvesting and processing foods deserve equitable pay for their work and safe working conditions, bringing social aspects of sustainability to the pet food system.

The contradictions to sustainability arise with conflicting consumer demands. For example, pet owners want muscle meat for their dog and cats, the same meats that people eat, while rejecting organ meats and rendered meat meals. Using large amounts of muscle meat in pet food places greater strain on farms, food prices and ecosystems. High-meat pet foods may raise prices in the butcher’s case while inflation already turns families’ steak nights to meatloaf. Even in the United States, federal statistics classify 10.5% of households as food insecure. On a societal level, this mean that pet owners feed human-grade meat to dogs while children remain malnourished a few blocks away. In many ways, the food system doesn’t meet the needs of present generations, so it fails the sustainability definition before even getting to the caveat about future generations.