During the 2014 Feed and Pet Food Joint Conference, October
7-9 in Omaha, Nebraska, USA, Daniel McChesney, PhD, director of the office of
surveillance and compliance for the US Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA)
Center for Veterinary Medicine, highlighted key revisions to the preventive
control rule for petfood and feed under the Food Safety Modernization Act
(FSMA).
McChesney said FDA received more than 2,100 comments to the original
proposed animal feed preventive control rule released in October 2013,
including many from consumers. Industry organizations, such as the Pet Food
Institute and National Grain and Feed Association (co-organizers of the Feed
and Pet Food Joint Conference), along with the American Feed Industry
Association, also offered in-depth feedback on the original rule.
With the re-proposed rule, which FDA released September 29, 2014,
and McChesney referred to as the supplemental proposed rule, the agency is only
asking for comments on new or revised areas, though it will accept comments on
other areas. FDA is accepting comments for 75 days from the release date.
During the 2014 Feed and Pet Food Joint Conference, October
7-9 in Omaha, Nebraska, USA, Daniel McChesney, PhD, director of the office of
surveillance and compliance for the US Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA)
Center for Veterinary Medicine, highlighted key revisions to the preventive
control rule for petfood and feed under the Food Safety Modernization Act
(FSMA).
McChesney said FDA received more than 2,100 comments to the original
proposed animal feed preventive control rule released in October 2013,
including many from consumers. Industry organizations, such as the Pet Food
Institute and National Grain and Feed Association (co-organizers of the Feed
and Pet Food Joint Conference), along with the American Feed Industry
Association, also offered in-depth feedback on the original rule.
With the re-proposed rule, which FDA released September 29, 2014,
and McChesney referred to as the supplemental proposed rule, the agency is only
asking for comments on new or revised areas, though it will accept comments on
other areas. FDA is accepting comments for 75 days from the release date.
The major revisions included in the supplemental rule,
McChesney said, include:
- A “very small business,” which would be exempt from
complying to some elements of the rule, is now defined as having less than
US$2.5 million in total annual sales of animal food, adjusted for inflation.
McChesney commented that 98% of the animal food (including petfood) industry in
the US would be covered outside this exclusion. However, he also said FDA is seeking
comments on whether dollar sales are the best measure for feed and petfood.
Would units of sale, for example, be better?
- Current good manufacturing practices (CGMPs), which were a
big area and focus of comments received, McChesney said; feedback to the
original proposed rule said it made CGMPs too prescriptive, too similar to ones
for human food and too stringent to be
prerequisites because of the diversity of animal food facilities. In response,
FDA modified that section of the rule, keeping the structure of human food
CGMPs but rewriting the ones for animal food to be less prescriptive. McChesney
said he thinks they're much closer to being appropriate for animal food but FDA
is still looking for comments.
- Under hazard analysis and critical control points (HACCP)
plans, comments to the original proposed rule expressed concern with use of the
word “known” in terms of identifying hazards, because that might have led to
food facilities needing to control every single conceivable hazard out
there. While McChesney said that was never FDA’s intent, the agency did
change the wording in the supplemental proposed rule to “significant hazards,”
also replacing the wording “reasonably likely to occur.”
McChesney commented that in written food safety plans, which
FSMA will require of every facility but very small businesses, manufacturers
will need to define hazards they are controlling—and how—outside of CGMPs. So, if
a facility has comprehensive CGMPs, it might have a very narrowly focused,
short safety plan.
With supplier verification, comments to the original
proposed rule agreed it's a good idea but didn't like how FDA proposed doing
it. So, McChesney said, FDA looked at the foreign supplier verification rule under
FSMA and how that might apply to domestic suppliers. In the supplemental
proposed rule, FDA is providing flexibility for each facility to determine
appropriate verification activities of its suppliers. However, it will likely
require an annual audit of significant hazards; unless you're controlling that
hazard at your facility, you should verify your supplier is controlling it.
Finally, in response to a question about how FDA inspectors
will be trained to enforce FSMA rules, McChesney said that at least initially,
inspectors will be looking mainly to see that facilities and their personnel
understand the rules and how their company is following them; they would not be
looking to write tickets for noncompliance. In other words, initial visits will
be focused on education, not compliance.